Commuting vs Renting a car: Which is more ideal?

When you’re planning a trip, then you have to think about how you’ll get around. For most people, the same debate ensues; should you commute via public transport, or should you rent a car?

Which option is better? Well, let’s take a look at a few key considerations to figure things out:


Most people automatically assume that commuting is the cheaper option. This may be the case, but only if you don’t travel around a lot, and there’s a small group of people. If you’re travelling with your family, then you might have to pay for 3, 4, or 5 different bus passes and train tickets whenever you go from place to place. On the other hand, renting a car has a fixed daily cost that won’t really change if you have a group of people. Whether you’re two people or a family of five; the price of the car you rent will remain the same. Also, you have the benefit of knowing exactly how much you’ll spend on transport as the costs are laid out for you daily.


The biggest downside of commuting is that you can’t always guarantee that you’ll have enough space. You might end up cramped together on a packed train, or squished up next to someone on a bus. This is where renting a car really comes out on top as you can choose a vehicle with as much space as you like. You could hire an estate car to provide ample room for three kids in the back plus two adults up front. There’s also the benefit of having space in a car boot to put any shopping bags, backpacks – or anything else you’re carrying around.


Much like space, your commuting experience depends on the specific bus or train that you’re on. Some might be comfortable, but some might be horrific – it’s a lottery! When you rent a car, you know you’re going to be comfortable. This is partly because everyone has their own personal space, but also because the seats are better, you have air-con and heating; it’s just an overall more comfortable experience.


Lastly, you need to consider the practicality of each option. Again, renting a car throws up some significant advantages. Mainly, you have the freedom to go wherever you want, whenever you want. There’s no need to conform to timetables or go to specific stops – it lets you plan a trip with more accuracy and less fuss. Also, if you’re travelling in large groups, then commuting is often terribly impractical. It’s hard to get a big group of people all on the same bus or train – especially at busy hours. But, you can always rent a minibus or a large car and take your group from place to place with ease. As such, car rentals end up being more practical.

So, you can see that renting a car does end up being the better option in most scenarios. You have more freedom to travel on your own schedule, more comfort, a great deal of space, and it’s cost-effective as well. Check for your rental needs.